I have a cheap ($200) Rossi welder off ebay, with the D-size Argon gas and BOC wire. At first it was shite, but I had a good mate who can weld come over, adjsust the settings, re-route the wire, re-attach the earth clamp, and now my welds are consistent, even to the point of being better than I expected.
For me, set up is crucial, as is CLEAN metal, but having said that, I had the use of a really good welder from a panel beater mate, and it was alot easier to work with. Still, the little Rossi has done most of my car reasonably well - and it's all I've got/can afford! Have a good go at setting yours up right I reckon and perhaps a high-quality earth clamp before selling it. If that still doesn't work, chuck her out! :-)